CCS Implementation of Surge Prevention Control System on Yokogawa Stardom PLC

Alexey Zelenov Director, Product Development Continuous Control Solutions

Introduction

Continuous Control Solutions ("CCS") has been providing advanced turbo machinery solutions to global markets since 2000 with a steadfast focus on developing advanced control algorithms implemented in the customer's choice of PLC or DCS hardware platform. CCS Turbo Machinery Control Solutions have been implemented on a variety of hardware platforms including Allen Bradley ControlLogix, Honeywell C300, Siemens S7, ABB AC800M and Emerson DeltaV. Due to the increasing demand for compressor and turbine control systems to be implemented in a common hardware with plant DCS, CCS has partnered with Yokogawa to offer advanced, proven and tested turbo machinery controls solutions on the Yokogawa Stardom PLC.

Yokogawa's development of its high-speed protection and servo I/O modules has indicated the company's strategic initiative to offer DCS customers the ability to achieve market-leading turbo machinery control in their Yokogawa hardware rather than settling for a third-party, "black-box" solution. In 2011, Yokogawa and CCS started collaboration on an R&D project to develop CCS's world-proven turbo machinery control applications for the Stardom PLC. In the summer of 2012, CCS completed the development of Yokogawa-approved library elements for compressor and turbine control within Stardom's LogicDesigner.

Customers are becoming more sensitive to the increasing costs of maintaining, servicing and providing spare parts for black-box turbo machinery control systems. The inability of black-box providers to consistently service obsolete controllers over time increases retrofit costs and forces otherwise unnecessary service visits and hardware upgrades. Allowing turbo machinery control to migrate from the realm of black-box solutions to systems which integrate seamlessly with a plant DCS provides a one-stop-shop for servicing hardware on site. In addition, customers can work with their DCS provider to negotiate favorable spare parts contracts for turbo machinery controllers that will be included in overall DCS spare parts agreements. Finally, operator screens, trending and general HMI functionality can be incorporated seamlessly into the plant DCS system, increasing transparency of the overall system.

Lukoil Karpatneftekhim Plant, Kalush, Ukraine

The air separation unit located at the Lukoil "Karpatneftekhim" plant in Kalush, Ukraine was designed and built in 1996. According to the CCS initial site survey report, the air compressor began experiencing problems starting in 2010:

  • Excessive vibration of the first stage of the compressor (YT1111)
  • Vibration of the suction line and service platform
  • Increased noise of the air flow in the area of the compressor.

These were all typical signs of unregulated compressor control resulting in multiple compressor surges over time. These findings were confirmed in the course of surge tests conducted during commissioning.

These issues were a major cause of up to 12 unscheduled plant shutdowns per year. As the existing control system was no longer capable of preventing the compressor from surging, the decision to replace the entire compressor control system was made. Further to CCS's successful implementation of the surge prevention control system on the chlorine compressor units at the same site, "Karpatneftekhim" appealed to CCS with a request to design a compressor control system for the air compressor unit. One of the requirements was to implement a Yokogawa hardware/software based solution since the plant was planning on upgrading to a Yokogawa Centum DCS in the near future. Part of the upgrade project is to maintain critical operating systems in a common hardware platform.

Figure 1: Process diagram of compressor C1161

Figure 1: Process diagram of compressor C1161

Site Details

The compressor (C1161) is a DEMAG multi-stage centrifugal compressor, model VK 32-3, driven by 4MW electric motor. Compressor was delivered in 1996 and designed to compress the process air up to ~ 6 atm g. After compression the air is directed to drying absorbers. Compressor VK 32-3 is a multi-shaft, three-stage compressor, with intercoolers after first and second stages. To maintain a wide range of operation, the compressor is equipped with pneumatic internal guide vanes (IGV). Flow and/or pressure of air supplied to the drying unit is used as the primary process variable. To protect compressor from surge a pneumatic antisurge valve (ASV) is used to vent the air to atmosphere at compressor's discharge.

Control System Function

The CCS Control System provides a significant increase in efficiency, reliability and stable operation of air compressor C1161 in the following operation modes:

  • compressor pre-start permissive verification;
  • start-up and loading of the compressor;
  • normal operation;
  • Unloading, Normal Stop and Emergency Shutdown.

The CCS Control System complements the existing control system and provides the following functions:

  • Anti-surge control for each stage
  • Surge counting when operating point of corresponding stage crosses the surge line
  • Compressor Surge tester feature
  • Compressor process visualization, i.e. compressor stages' operating points and efficiencies at actual speed
  • Maintains primary process variable
  • Limits motor maximum power consumption
  • Dedicated HMI and CCS Configurator

The main objective of surge control is to maintain the minimum flow rate through the compressor determined at the surge line with the addition of the required safety margins. The CCS control system provides anti-surge control and protection by venting the minimum required amount of air to atmosphere through the antisurge valve. The control system automatically maintains the main process variable by either manipulating the inlet guide vane installed in the compressor's inlet or, if necessary, controlling the compressor anti-surge valve.

Implementation

The CCS Control Solution was implemented on the Yokogawa Stardom hardware/software platform. To conform with project requirements a controller with CPU NFCP100 (in redundant configuration) was selected. This CPU is capable of providing high performance for various applications with minimum execution time of 40ms, in-line with market anti- surge requirements, competitive offerings and the needs of the plant.

Based on results from start-up and commissioning of the control system, the PLC has demonstrated high levels of performance. The logic program along with CCS control applications run within CPU control environment in tasks with 40ms, 250ms and 500ms execution cycles. I/O processing, one Process Controller (PC) and three Surge Prevention Controllers (SPC), one per each stage, were assigned to the 40ms tasks. 250ms is configured for tasks which perform logic control functions such as sequencing for loading and unloading of the compressor, various trips, etc. 500ms has been assigned to task, which is responsible for the Modbus communication of the compressor control system with existing DCS. CPU load during operation at full capacity did not exceed 37% (Figure 3).

Figure 2-3: Operator Interface, main screen; CPU Load
Figure 2: Operator Interface, main screen Figure 3: CPU Load

CCS's Surge Prevention Control and Process Control applications along with logic control functions have been designed and implemented utilizing Yokogawa's engineering tool Logic Designer. This environment supports standard IEC6131 programming languages and provides advanced debugging tools, providing for significantly lower time spent on software development. The development of the Surge Prevention Controller and Process Controller came down to a simple adaptation of existing, proven and in-operation CCS control applications (from other platforms) to the Yokogawa Stardom platform.

Figure 4: CCS libraries in Logic Designer environment

Figure 4: CCS libraries in Logic Designer environment

Yokogawa's Fast / Tools 9.05 software package is used for operator interface (HMI) (Figure 5).

Figure 5: SCADA Fast/Tools 9.05

Figure 5: SCADA Fast/Tools 9.05

Figure 6: CCS Configurator

Figure 6: CCS Configurator

This SCADA system offers a high degree of integration with the family of Yokogawa controllers, allowing less time for HMI development.

CCS Configurator is a tool used for configuration of the CCS control system. Configurator is connected directly to controller via Yokogawa ExaOPC OPC server and has access to application configuration parameters of the SPC and PC (Figure 6).

Surge tests of the compressor C1161 were conducted during start-up and commissioning (Figure 7). A total of six tests for various angular positions of the inlet guide vanes were performed and precise surge line for each individual stage has been determined as a result.

Figure 7: Sample trend of surge tests

Figure 7: Sample trend of surge tests: Rapid drop of flow at the compressor's suction CPU Load

Figure 8: Calling procedure of SPC function block

Figure 8: Calling procedure of SPC function block

Surge Prevention Controller

Figure 9: SPC Faceplate
Figure 9: SPC Faceplate

CCS' patented Surge Prevention Control (SPC) method defines the compressor surge line over a wide range of changing conditions and allows setting of the compressor surge prevention control line for optimum surge protection without unnecessary recycling or blow-off. This method allows for accurate calculation of proximity to surge even when the flow measurement fails or is not available.

Surge Prevention Controller application is developed as an independent function block in the Logic Designer environment and used as custom plug-in to the project library. The function block offers a full set of features available in CCS's standard Surge Prevention Controller implemented on any other hardware and software platforms, including patented algorithms for anti-surge protection.

SPC function block has a set of input and output parameters, which interface the application's internal variables with real I/O from a separate I/O processing block, allowing maximum "embedding" capabilities. Management of the controller from external logic is performed by manipulating boolean variables of corresponding command inputs of the function block. Refer to Figure 8 for sample calling procedure of SPC function block.

To perform functions by operators a standard SPC faceplate is offered (Figure 9).

The panel allows operators to monitor status and current mode of operation of the controller as well as to change various modes of operation by commands available for selection via corresponding menu. The operator may take the controller into manual mode using the faceplate and view various controller PID loops. The controller will ensure safe operation of the compressor's anti-surge valve at all times.

Figure 10: Surge Test window
Figure 10: Surge Test window

Additionally, when controller is switched to Surge Test, a separate popup window allows using the embedded functionality that is intended to help qualified engineering personnel during surge tests of the compressor (Figure 10).

To allow operators to monitor the current operation of the compressor stage, CCS's Compressor Map application is delivered as a part of operator interface. The Compressor Map indicates the position of the operating point of the compressor stage relative to the surge limit and pressure characteristics of the compressor (Figure 11). The Compressor Map application features the following:

  • Zooming in and out of the operating area;
  • Displaying of operating point's values and current operation conditions;
  • Precise tracing of the operating point position;
  • Simultaneous calculations and displaying capability in various coordinates;
  • Capability to save screenshots for printing.

The Compressor Map and Faceplate are parts of operator interface implemented in Fast/Tools 9.05 SCADA system and can be invoked by clicking on dynamic elements on the display (buttons, etc.).

The CCS Surge Prevention Control application additionally offers the following features:

  • Figure 11: Compressor Map
    Figure 11: Compressor Map
    Surge Detector
    The method of surge detection is based on calculating the discharge pressure or the rate of change in the compressor's flow rate and comparing it with established limits. With this algorithm, the surge line automatically shifts at a given distance and triggers step-by-step opening of the re-circulation valve.
  • Controller Calibration
    Controller setting line may be defined experimentally or by calculation. For the experimental adjustment of the anti- surge controller setting line, a few surge tests have to be done. For compressors with variable speed and/or inlet guide vanes (IGV) surge test should be carried out at different speeds or in different IGV positions.
    Calculated line configuration can be defined mathematically, based on the theoretical gas dynamic characteristics of the compressor, provided by the manufacturer. Calibrated surge points must be configured within the controller, which then automatically interpolate the surge line linearly.
  • «Impact by derivative» Control Algorithm
    Using a differential component in the traditional form of PID under normal operating conditions leads to system instability and therefore is not used in the SPC. However, under rapidly changing process conditions, the standard PI control action is insufficient for surge prevention. In general, under normal conditions, the rate of the controller is not a critical parameter, but due to high speeds associated with compressor surge cycles (~0.3s), effective surge prevention can only be achieved with fast controllers. For the rapid flow decrease, CCS utilizes the "impact by derivative" algorithm for opening the anti-surge valve before the operating point reaches its line limit. Once the system returns to a stable state, it resumes the PI regulation.
  • Limiting Pressure Regulation
    In order to limit the discharge or suction pressure, the SPC includes an additional control loop, which increases recycling.
  • Fallback Strategies
    Fallback Strategy algorithms are configured in accordance with the specifications of the manufacturer and ensure continuous and safe unit operation in case any sensors or measuring channels fail.
  • Loading and Unloading Modes
    The SPC includes configurable algorithms for loading and unloading the compressor in accordance with the manufacturer's specifications and technology requirements.

Process Controller

Figure 12: PC Faceplate
Figure 12: PC Faceplate

The package includes the Process Controller application which is used to control the performance (e.g., discharge or suction pressure, flow rate, motor current) of the compressor and can provide precise capacity control by manipulating position of a guide vane of the compressor. Process Controller can also provide limiting control of any other parameter of the compressor.

Process Controller application similarly to SPC is developed as an independent function block in the Logic Designer environment and used as custom plug-in to the project library. The function block offers a full set of features available in CCS's standard Process Controller implemented on any other hardware and software platform.

PC function block has a set of input and output parameters, which interfaces application's internal variables with real I/O from separate I/O processing block allowing maximum "embedding" capabilities. Management of the controller from external logic is performed by manipulating boolean variables of corresponding command inputs of the function block.

To perform functions by operators a standard PC faceplate is offered (Figure 12).

The panel allows operators to monitor status and current mode of operation of the controller as well as to change various modes of operation by commands available for selection via corresponding menu.

Conclusion

Over the period of operation the compressor control system has proven its effectiveness as the controlling compressor became "transparent." Plant personnel have obtained the ability to clearly monitor the nature of the physical processes that take place in the compressor; for example, when the compressor operating point approaches or is near to the surge line. This gives operators the ability to perform actions directed to prevent unnecessary opening of anti-surge valve due to process conditions. Upon reaching critical conditions the old system simple opened the anti-surge valve to 100%, resulting in a complete compressor discharge, followed frequently by an emergency plant shutdown. The new CCS control system avoids such situations as it opens anti-surge valve the minimum amount necessary to ensure that a minimum flow of air through the compressor is maintained to prevent surge.

Accuracy of the regulation of the main process variable (discharge pressure of the compressor) is approximately 0.01bar, which exceeds performance of the old system. This allows the process to gain more stable conditions.

As it turned out during project execution, the problems (multiple surges) described at the beginning of the document arose from clogging of compressor's intercoolers, which the operation personnel was unable to recognize in advance. During modernization phase the pressure sensors were installed at the suction and discharge of each compressor stage. Thus, the operation personnel is able to recognize in advance the degree of clogging of the intercoolers by monitoring the differential pressure on them, as corresponding alarms and interlocks are available in the system, and perform necessary preventive actions to maintain the equipment in good operating condition.

The CCS compressor control system installed at the Lukoil "Karpatneftekhim" plant in Kalush, Ukraine marks the first- ever Yokogawa Stardom-based compressor control system implemented as part of the growing Yokogawa/CCS relationship. It marks a very important point in the development of the turbo machinery controls market, demonstrating to customers that what was previously designated solely for black-box providers of proprietary control systems is now possible to execute in the customer's choice of hardware, adding flexibility to installing new or upgrading old automation systems.

WHITE PAPER:
SPC/PC ON YOKOGAWA
STARDOM E.001.130604
BY: A. ZELENOV JUNE 2013.
WWW.CCSIA.COM

The contents of this publication are presented for informational purposes only, and while every effort has been made to ensure their accuracy, they are not to be construed warrantees or guarantees, express or implied, regarding the products or services described herein or their use or applicability. All sales are governed by our terms and conditions, which are available on request. We reserve the right to modify or improve the design or specification of such products at any time without notice.

Continuous Control Solutions
11275 Aurora Avenue
Des Moines, IA USA
50322
www.ccsia.com

Related Products & Solutions

Main Automation Contractor (MAC)

Yokogawa's main automation contractor (MAC) service delivers the full scope of project execution capabilities. Yokogawa assumes responsibility over the entire automation related aspects of the project, helping you meet budget, time, manpower, delivery, and risk management needs.

Procedural Automation (Exapilot)

Procedural Automation (Exapilot) provides a flexible methodology to capture, optimize and retain procedural knowledge in a process plant while meeting requirements in reliability, flexibility, and lifecycle costs.

SCADA Software (FAST/TOOLS)

Originating as the Flexible Advanced System Techniques (FAST) project, FAST/TOOLS today is a comprehensive, fully-integrated SCADA application suite. Powerful and flexible, FAST/TOOLS serves installations ranging from 50-point unit processes to multimillion-point offshore production and pipeline systems that extend over thousands of miles.

Program Controllers

The UP35A/UP55A, 1/4 DIN sized program controllers, provides up to 30 program patterns, and simultaneous monitoring of 8 PV events, 16 time events, and 8 alarms.

Programmable Logic Controllers (PLC/PAC)

Yokogawa’s PLC products feature ultra-high speed, stable control and high-performance networking for real time, deterministic automation and monitoring.

×

Have Questions?

Contact a Yokogawa Expert to learn how we can help you solve your challenges.

Top